As of Nov. 12 - we have room for a few gallons on the weekends. Cherry Rock is full right now.

Plastic vs. Glass Jars for Raw Milk: Which is the Best Choice?

written by

Olivia Amundson

posted on

October 6, 2025

If you drink raw milk, you already know freshness and quality are everything. But did you know the container you store raw milk in can affect flavor, safety, and shelf life? Choosing between plastic vs. glass jars for raw milk isn’t just about convenience—it impacts freshness, safety, cost, and sustainability.

Let’s explore the differences so you can decide which container is best for your family.

Freshness and Taste: Raw Milk in Glass vs. Plastic

One of the biggest factors in raw milk storage is freshness. The container plays a direct role in how long raw milk tastes sweet, clean, and true to its natural flavor.

Glass Keeps Milk Pure and Fresh

Glass jars are non-porous, meaning they don’t absorb odors from the fridge or interact with raw milk’s delicate fats and proteins. The result? Milk that tastes pure, clean, and unaltered—from the first pour to the last.

Plastic Can Affect Flavor

Plastic containers are slightly porous. Over time, they can absorb odors (like onions or leftovers in the fridge) and may leach trace compounds into the milk. Scratches in plastic can also trap bacteria, which can shorten freshness and alter flavor.

Shelf Life Advantage

Both plastic and glass keep milk cold in the refrigerator, but glass has an edge—it retains cold longer once removed. Many raw milk drinkers report their milk tastes fresher for more days when stored in glass compared to plastic.

✅ If you’re asking how to keep raw milk fresh longer, glass jars are the gold standard.

Safety: Plastic vs. Glass Jars for Raw Milk

Safety in raw milk containers isn’t just about temperature—it’s also about the material itself.

Breakage and Handling

  • Glass jars: Can break or shatter if dropped, creating a hazard in busy kitchens or around kids.
  • Plastic containers: Won’t break if dropped, making them safer for travel or households on the go.

Chemical Safety

  • Glass jars: 100% inert. They won’t leach chemicals or interact with milk.
  • Plastic containers: Food-grade, BPA-free plastics are safe, but lower-quality plastics may leach chemicals over time, especially if exposed to heat.

Sanitization & Hygiene

  • Glass: Easy to sterilize in boiling water or the dishwasher. Scratch-resistant, leaving fewer spots for bacteria to hide.
  • Plastic: Prone to scratching, which creates places for bacteria to linger. Must be replaced more often to maintain hygiene.

Temperature Stability

Glass holds temperature longer, which helps raw milk stay cold and safe. Plastic warms faster and may warp under heat.

👉 If your priority is safe raw milk storage, glass is the clear winner.

Cost Comparison: Plastic vs. Glass Jars for Raw Milk

When families choose containers, cost of raw milk storage is often top of mind. At first glance, plastic seems cheaper—but the long-term math tells another story.

Upfront Price

  • Plastic: Lower initial cost, especially when bought in bulk.
  • Glass: Higher upfront investment, especially for gallon or half-gallon jars.

Durability & Lifespan

  • Glass: Can last indefinitely if handled carefully.
  • Plastic: Scratches, stains, and warps over time, requiring replacement if reusing.

Replacement Costs

  • Glass: Rarely needs replacing unless broken.
  • Plastic: Needs regular replacement, adding up over time.

Environmental Costs

Glass is recyclable and endlessly reusable. Plastic is less eco-friendly and often ends up in landfills.

✅ Bottom Line: Glass jars save money in the long run and are the more sustainable choice.

Sustainability: Raw Milk and Eco-Friendly Containers

For families who value sustainable raw milk practices, the choice between plastic and glass is clear.

  • Glass: Reusable, recyclable, and environmentally safe.
  • Plastic: Lower upfront cost, but higher long-term environmental impact.

If supporting the planet is part of your values, glass jars for raw milk align best with sustainability.

Convenience: When Plastic Makes Sense

While glass often wins on freshness, safety, and sustainability, plastic still has its place.

  • Lighter to carry
  • Safer for travel (no risk of breaking in the car)
  • Handy for families with young kids or busy schedules

👉 If convenience is your priority, plastic may work better for short-term storage and transport.

Final Verdict: Should You Store Raw Milk in Plastic or Glass?

When weighing freshness, safety, cost, sustainability, and convenience, here’s the breakdown:

  • Glass jars: Best for freshness, flavor, safety, and long-term savings.
  • Plastic containers: Best for convenience and break-resistance.

✨ The Bottom Line: If you want to keep raw milk as fresh, safe, and pure as possible, glass jars are the gold standard. But for families who prioritize convenience, plastic containers can still serve as a practical short-term option.

raw milk, plastic, glass, jars, freshness, safety, cost, sustainability

More from the blog

What To Do When You Have Too Much Raw Milk

What To Do When You Have Too Much Raw Milk

I was visiting with a friend the other day about milk — how some weeks it seems to disappear faster than we can blink, and other times it ends up sitting in the fridge longer than we’d like. 🥛 When it comes to raw milk, every drop feels precious. It’s the good stuff — straight from the farm, and in my perspective, a lot of work— and the last thing I ever want to do is let it go to waste.  So here are some things I do when I need to use up some extra milk. Hot Chocolate or Latte’s Something about the colder months just calls for a warm drink in hand — a cozy cup of hot chocolate, or a creamy coffee or tea latte made with fresh milk. ☕️ And when summer rolls around, an iced tea latte hits the spot just right — cool, refreshing, and a whole lot better than most of those sugary summer drinks.  Easy Hot Chocolate Recipe 1 cup raw milk 1 TBSP raw cacao 1 TBSP honey or maple syrup 1. Heat milk with a coffee frother or on the stove.2. Once at desired temp, add the cacao and the honey (maple syrup) to taste.3. Mix or whip until combined Tea Latte 1 tea packet or loose leaf tea of choice ½ cup water (can use less depending on cup size) ½ cup raw milk (can use less or more depending on cup size) 1-2 TBSP honey or maple syrup 1. Heat water and steep desired tea.2. Add tea to a cup with honey or maple syrup.3. Froth the milk and add to tea. Waffles I never realized how much milk a batch of waffles can take until I started making them for my boys. Around here, waffles disappear faster than I can stack them! 🧇 So now, on slower mornings, I mix up a big bowl of batter with our fresh raw milk and cook them up by the dozen. Once they’re cooled, I tuck them into the freezer—ready for those busy mornings when chores are calling and hungry boys come running. Nothing fancy, just good, wholesome food made from the milk our cows worked hard to give us. The recipe provided is courtesy of Thankfulhomemaking.com, however, multiple waffle recipes work as they all tend to use a good amount of milk.  Butter Milk Waffles 2 cups flour 2 TBSP sugar 2 tsp baking powder 1 tsp baking soda ½ tsp salt 2 ½ cups butter milk – (to make butter milk add 2.5 TBSP vinegar or lemon juice to the milk) 1/3 cup butter, melted 2 eggs 1 tsp vanilla 1.  In a large bowl, mix together the buttermilk and melted butter.  Add the eggs and vanilla and mix well. In another bowl, whisk together flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda, and salt. 2. Add dry ingredients to the wet ingredients and whisk until just combined.  Then let batter rest while you preheat your waffle iron. 3. Pour batter into waffle iron and cook until ready 4. Extras can be frozen nicely for later use.  Yogurt Yogurt is one of our favorite ways to put extra milk to good use. It’s simple, wholesome, and so versatile — perfect as a base for smoothies, a stand-in for sour cream in recipes, or just enjoyed on its own with a drizzle of honey and a handful of fresh fruit. There’s something special about that creamy, homemade goodness straight from your own milk supply. 🥛🍯 There are multiple ways that yogurt can be made and simply without any special kitchen appliances, however, one of my favorite recipes includes the use of an insta pot and is fool proof.  Recipe courtesy of FarmHouseOnBoone.com Yogurt ½ gallon whole milk (raw in this case) ¼ cup yogurt culture or plain yogurt 1. Pour the ½ gallon of milk in the insta pot and press the “saute” button.  Heat the milk to 180 while whisking constantly.2. Once the milk reaches 180, turn off “saute” option and allow milk to cool back down to 115.3. Add in ¼ cup of plain yogurt or starter culture and whisk into milk.4. Set insta pot for 8-24 hours on the yogurt setting. 5. Once the timer goes off you can transfer the yogurt to a container and chill or to make a little thicker, strain in a cheese cloth for up to an hour.    Smoothies Without a doubt, smoothies are one of the easiest (though not always the tidiest!) ways to use up extra milk — especially when you’re blending for a crowd of hungry kids. The best part? The flavor possibilities are endless. Here are a few of our family’s favorite go-to smoothie combinations that never fail to please. 🥛🍓🍌 Chocolate Peanut Butter Smoothie 1 cup whole raw milk ½ cup raw milk yogurt (or plain regular yogurt) ¼ cup peanut butter 1 frozen banana 1 TBSP cacao powder 1. Place all ingredients in a blender.2. Blend until smooth and incorporated.3. Transfer to a cup to enjoy. Berry Smoothie 1 cup whole raw milk ½ cup raw milk yogurt (or plain regular yogurt) ½ cup frozen berries of choice 1 frozen banana 1 TBSP chia seeds, flax seed, hemp seed or whatever you may like 1. Place all ingredients in a blender.2. Blend until smooth and incorporated.3. Transfer to a cup to enjoy. I know there are a hundred other ways to put that extra milk to good use, but we’ll stop here for today. Maybe in the next blog, we’ll chat about soups and cream bases — perfect ways to keep every drop of that milk working for you. Until then, if you’ve got a little extra in the fridge, give one of these ideas a try and keep that precious raw milk from going to waste. 🥛✨

Read more
Let’s Talk About Freshness: Why Raw Milk Isn’t Meant to Last Forever

Let’s Talk About Freshness: Why Raw Milk Isn’t Meant to Last Forever

Raw milk is a living, fresh food, not meant to sit in the fridge for months like processed dairy. Just like fresh raspberries, it’s natural for raw milk to change over time. When it starts to sour after a week or two, that doesn’t mean it’s “bad”—it’s simply evolving as nature intended. Unlike pasteurized milk, which spoils and molds, raw milk ferments safely thanks to its natural enzymes and beneficial bacteria. This souring process can even create delicious new products like clabbered milk, sour cream, or homemade cheese. To enjoy it at its best, drink raw milk within 7–10 days of purchase and store it properly: Keep it in the coldest part of the fridge (not the door). Always seal the lid tightly to slow souring. Avoid transferring it into new containers to prevent contamination. Raw milk doesn’t “expire”—it transforms. Embrace its freshness, flavor, and life-giving qualities by enjoying it close to the source—straight from the farm, the way nature intended.

Read more
What To Do With Raw Milk Cream?

What To Do With Raw Milk Cream?

Raw milk cream is one of the richest, most versatile parts of farm-fresh milk — perfect for everything from sweet treats to nourishing everyday meals. Its natural flavor and nutrients make it a staple in any traditional kitchen. You can turn raw cream into indulgent desserts like homemade ice cream, whipped cream, or butter, or use it in everyday ways such as coffee creamer, oatmeal, or smoothies. In the kitchen, raw cream adds richness to sauces, soups, baked goods, and cultured creations like sour cream, clotted cream, or European-style cultured butter. For convenience, raw cream freezes well, though fresh cream makes the best butter. ✨ Whether whipped, churned, or cultured, raw milk cream is a wholesome, flavorful ingredient that brings old-fashioned goodness to modern kitchens.

Read more
Return To Top

Follow Us

Join Our Newsletter

Countryside Mercantile


  • SD
  • 605-951-9441 info@countrysidemerc.com